Choosing the Best Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

Choosing the Best Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

Shaving can be a daily ritual for many men, but for dudes with sensitive skin, it can quickly turn into a nightmare. The good news is that choosing the right shaving cream can make a world of difference.

Below, we give great direction in determining if you have sensitive skin and how to go about navigating the wide world of different shaving cream options so that you may make the best choice and not get burned - pun intended.

Don’t feel like learning about how to choose the best shaving cream? No worries, Dude - scroll to the bottom of this article for a quick answer on why our recommendation for the best shaving cream on the market is actually Illegal.

★★★★★ 4.9/5

Illegal Shaving Cream -2PK

How to tell if you have sensitive skin.

Detecting sensitive skin often involves observing specific signs and conditions. One common indicator is "Rosacea," characterized by persistent redness, visible blood vessels, and sometimes pimples. "Contact Dermatitis" is another telltale sign, manifesting as redness, itching, and even blisters upon contact with allergenic substances.
Sensitivity can also lead to "Xerosis," which is a fancy term for excessive dryness. Your skin might feel tight, rough, or even develop flaky patches. "Prickly Heat" or "Heat Rash" is a reaction to heat and sweat, resulting in tiny, itchy bumps.
Furthermore, sensitive skin may react to sun exposure with "Photosensitivity," causing quicker and more severe sunburns. Lastly, if you often experience discomfort or redness after trying new skincare products, it could be "Contact Allergies."
If you notice these signs and conditions, you may have sensitive skin and should always be careful to choose products that do not further irritate your skin. You may also want to see a doctor.

Patch Testing Shaving Cream

Patch testing is like a sneak peek for your skin before the big show. Here's how you do it with a new shaving cream:
Here's the drill: Pick a low-key test spot, maybe your wrist or forearm, and make sure it's clean and dry. Now, apply a small amount of the new shaving cream following the product's instructions. Give it 24 hours without any other products joining the party. Keep an eye out for redness, itching, or any unexpected irritation. If these uninvited guests show up, wash it off ASAP.
But hey, some skin reactions take their sweet time. So, keep an eye on that test zone for up to 72 hours because latecomers can crash the party. If your skin behaves like a champ during this time, you're good to go.
Remember, everyone's skin is a bit different, so especially if you've got sensitive or itchy skin, this pre-shave preview is your skin-saver. It helps you avoid any shaving showdowns and keeps your skin feeling smooth and happy.

Ingredients to Avoid when Choosing a Shaving Cream

Alright, let's talk about the shaving creams that your sensitive skin would prefer you steer clear of – because nobody likes the red, itchy aftermath of a bad shave.
First off, say "no thanks" to shaving creams that are alcohol-heavy. These guys can be as drying as the Sahara Desert, leaving your skin parched and cranky. Opt for the alcohol-free champs to keep your skin's moisture game strong.
Foaming shaving creams might look cool, but they can be a bit rough on sensitive skin due to their foamy additives. These additives sometimes contain sulfates, known irritants that can leave your skin less than thrilled. Consider making the switch to non-foaming or creamy options for a kinder shave.
Watch out for those shaving gels that are astringent powerhouses. They can strip away your skin's natural oils, leaving it feeling tight and out of sorts. Instead, look for shaving gels and light creams that offer a milder, soothing experience.
And one more thing… expired shaving cream? Nah, toss it.. Over time, the ingredients can break down and become less effective, and who wants that? Always check those expiration dates and keep your products fresh and effective.
Remember, not all shaving creams play nice with sensitive skin. So, go for products that are designed with your skin's needs in mind. Treat your face with care, and it'll reward you with a smooth, irritation-free shave. Your skin deserves nothing less!

Shaving Cream Ingredients for Sensitive Skin

While not the rule, generally speaking, the following ingredients list is considered to be good for people with sensitive skin. When trying any new shaving creams for the first time, it’s important to utilize the patch test method, described above to ensure you have no adverse reactions.

  1. Water: This might seem obvious, but water is the essential base for any good shaving cream. It ensures a smooth, even application, which is crucial for sensitive skin.

  2. Glycerin: Glycerin is a hydration powerhouse. It draws moisture into your skin, keeping it supple and preventing the dryness that can lead to irritation.

  3. Stearic Acid: Derived from coconut oil, stearic acid helps create that luxurious, creamy lather in your shaving cream. It provides a protective cushion for your skin, reducing the risk of nicks and irritation.

  4. Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil: Coconut oil is a natural wonder for sensitive skin. It's deeply moisturizing and has soothing properties that can calm any post-shave redness.

  5. Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E): Vitamin E is a skincare superhero. It's an antioxidant that can protect your skin from damage while also providing moisture and soothing benefits, which are essential for sensitive skin.

  6. Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil: Olive oil is a natural emollient that can help lock in moisture and soothe sensitive skin during and after shaving. It's an excellent addition to shaving creams for its hydration benefits.

  7. Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract: Aloe vera is renowned for its soothing properties. It can alleviate irritation and reduce redness, making it a go-to ingredient for sensitive skin.

  8. Sodium Hyaluronate: This is the fancy name for hyaluronic acid, which is a hydration powerhouse. It keeps your skin plump and moisturized during your shave.

  9. Niacinamide: Niacinamide, also known as Vitamin B3, is known for its skin-soothing properties. It can reduce redness and irritation, making it a fantastic addition to shaving creams for sensitive skin.

  10. Panthenol: Panthenol, or Vitamin B5, is another skin-calming ingredient. It helps to hydrate your skin and reduce redness, leaving your post-shave skin feeling cool and comfortable.

The Best Shaving Cream May Actually be Illegal!

As a man who likes to rock a solid beard, I rarely have to battle with shaving creams these days, but I constantly had to fight this task in my earlier professional years, and let me tell ya dude - it sucked!
My skin is sensitive, much like my heart🤪, and I have tried just about every shaving cream product and razor on the market over the years. Most of my experiences have been terrible as so many of today’s shaving creams are packed full of crazy chemicals like parabens and even contain explosive chemicals like propane & isobutane.  
Here at Derm Dude, we pride ourselves on doing the necessary research and using the safest ingredients when developing our unique line of skincare products. As such, we decided to create, what we consider the most outstanding shaving cream to ever be invented - Illegal Shaving Cream.
Illegal shaving cream is great for men & women alike and has that special added touch of being a great choice for those with sensitive skin, like myself. Check the ingredient list - you’ll see.
Each order of Illegal Shaving Cream comes with 5 FREE premium, disposable razors to ensure the closest shave possible - you’re welcome dude!


When you have sensitive skin, the right shaving cream can make all the difference. Look for products containing these soothing and hydrating ingredients, and consider opting for paraben & explosion-free options. Your skin will thank you with a comfortable, irritation-free shaving experience. Remember, a little extra care in choosing the right shaving cream can go a long way in keeping your skin happy and looking its best.


★★★★★ 4.9/5

Illegal Shaving Cream

1 comment

  • Drew G on

    I h ave found a few shaving creams that don’t break my face out and one thing that is unique to them is they are non-foaming creams, more like a lotion than a shaving cream. Do you have a non-scented version? I hate the scents.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published